The Tulsa Forum by TulsaNow

Non-Tulsa Discussions => Chat and Advice => Topic started by: HoneySuckle on March 13, 2008, 01:59:10 PM

Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: HoneySuckle on March 13, 2008, 01:59:10 PM
I called Victory Christian school today to ask about subbing there since I am a sub at Union High School.  Figured a nice, Christian or private type environment might be less problematic than the public school.

Only reason I picked this one is because I'm not too far from there, and also Holland Hall has their subs all in place.

Shocker, at least to me is that I was told you HAD to be a member of Victory Christian Church!

Is that legal?  Isn't that discrimination of some type?  Catholic schools hire non-Catholics, and so does Metro Christian (going to sub for them).

Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Conan71 on March 13, 2008, 02:22:20 PM
Not much different than ORU requiring all employees to be non-tobacco users.

Being a private school, there's a whole lot of things they can include and exclude which a public school cannot.

If Cascia or BK wanted to limit employment strictly to Augustinian or Jesuit priests it's well within their rights.

Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: restored2x on March 13, 2008, 02:25:36 PM
It doesn't shock me, but it also doesn't sound right. Did they give you any reasons why they have that policy?

I'd also like to know the answer to your question. Maybe a legal eagle on here could school us (pun unintentional). Wouldn't that be discrimination based on religion? Or because of the "private" in private school, they can hire who they please?
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: RecycleMichael on March 13, 2008, 02:32:48 PM
Did you consider joining the church, getting the job, then suddenly getting real busy on Sundays?

Do they take attendance?

It is not for me, but we have friends who attend there and they really like it.

Most of us could use a little more church-ifying.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: sgrizzle on March 13, 2008, 02:37:12 PM
Victory also doesn't allow sex other than in the missionary position. Little shocks me.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: cannon_fodder on March 13, 2008, 02:40:46 PM
As a religion and a non-profit they have a ton of leeway.  Though as an educational institution they probably get some state funding.

Wow, that is a great question.

I believe the answer is YES.  They have a good argument that hiring only members is essential to their stated mission of providing a moral education.  As a religious enterprise they can discriminate based on religion to a large degree AND membership institutions can give preference to members.

Not my area of study, but I think they are in the clear.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: cannon_fodder on March 13, 2008, 02:41:23 PM
quote:
Originally posted by sgrizzle

Victory also doesn't allow sex other than in the missionary position. Little shocks me.



Is this sarcasm or doctrine?  I can't take anything religious as sarcasm anymore because too often it's reality.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: sgrizzle on March 13, 2008, 02:49:45 PM
quote:
Originally posted by cannon_fodder

quote:
Originally posted by sgrizzle

Victory also doesn't allow sex other than in the missionary position. Little shocks me.



Is this sarcasm or doctrine?  I can't take anything religious as sarcasm anymore because too often it's reality.



Not sarcasm, unfortunately. They have some sort of sex-ed class that states this.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: tulsa_fan on March 13, 2008, 02:54:23 PM
I wonder if that policy only applies to subs?  I could see that more than across the board, subs are temporary in and out pepole and maybe they are more comfortable with them being members of their church.  I don't think that's really wrong, it is the church the established the school.  

Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Kashmir on March 13, 2008, 03:17:00 PM
I used to teach at a Catholic School in the Diocese and you wouldn't believe the packet I had to fill out upon application.  I had to get a priest's letter, etc.  However, I believe you can call the school office of any of the Catholic schools and they can hook you up with what you may need to be a sub-if you are interested.  I think all you need is the VIRTUS workshop.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Conan71 on March 13, 2008, 04:02:41 PM
quote:
Originally posted by sgrizzle

quote:
Originally posted by cannon_fodder

quote:
Originally posted by sgrizzle

Victory also doesn't allow sex other than in the missionary position. Little shocks me.



Is this sarcasm or doctrine?  I can't take anything religious as sarcasm anymore because too often it's reality.



Not sarcasm, unfortunately. They have some sort of sex-ed class that states this.



You know why Baptists don't have sex standing up?

They're afraid someone would see them and think they were dancing.

Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Townsend on March 13, 2008, 04:49:16 PM
quote:
Originally posted by tulsa_fan

I wonder if that policy only applies to subs?  I could see that more than across the board, subs are temporary in and out pepole and maybe they are more comfortable with them being members of their church.  I don't think that's really wrong, it is the church the established the school.  





"subs are temporary in and out pepole"

The missionary thing?
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Wilbur on March 13, 2008, 06:40:34 PM
I think the word PRIVATE in your topic line pretty much answers the question.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: HoneySuckle on March 13, 2008, 09:11:57 PM
quote:
Originally posted by tulsa_fan

I wonder if that policy only applies to subs?  I could see that more than across the board, subs are temporary in and out pepole and maybe they are more comfortable with them being members of their church.  I don't think that's really wrong, it is the church the established the school.  







No.  A friend called about 3 hours later enquiring about employment as a counsellor and was told the same.  She then asked if this rule applied only to teachers, part-time workers and counsellors, and was told that it applied to ALL employees working at the school.

And no.  I would never dream of joining their church.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Nick Danger on March 13, 2008, 10:14:52 PM
Our kids went to Grace a few years ago, and they have the same policy for all teachers. We felt this was so restrictive that the quality of teachers probably suffered, because of the smaller  pool to choose from. The lower grades were great, but the we encountered some unqualified teachers in the HS, as the subject matter became more specialized.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Conan71 on March 13, 2008, 11:37:51 PM
quote:
Originally posted by HoneySuckle

quote:
Originally posted by tulsa_fan

I wonder if that policy only applies to subs?  I could see that more than across the board, subs are temporary in and out pepole and maybe they are more comfortable with them being members of their church.  I don't think that's really wrong, it is the church the established the school.  





No.  A friend called about 3 hours later enquiring about employment as a counsellor and was told the same.  She then asked if this rule applied only to teachers, part-time workers and counsellors, and was told that it applied to ALL employees working at the school.

And no.  I would never dream of joining their church.



What about Metro Christian?

How about sweet revenge on your Rush Limbaugh friend.  Start every sentence with "Well Brother Billy Joe says...."
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: mr.jaynes on March 14, 2008, 06:12:22 PM
quote:
Originally posted by Conan71

Not much different than ORU requiring all employees to be non-tobacco users.

Being a private school, there's a whole lot of things they can include and exclude which a public school cannot.

If Cascia or BK wanted to limit employment strictly to Augustinian or Jesuit priests it's well within their rights.



With that in mind, a Jesuit education is a quality education indeed.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: restored2x on March 15, 2008, 09:22:10 AM
quote:
Originally posted by Conan71

quote:
Originally posted by sgrizzle

quote:
Originally posted by cannon_fodder

quote:
Originally posted by sgrizzle

Victory also doesn't allow sex other than in the missionary position. Little shocks me.



Is this sarcasm or doctrine?  I can't take anything religious as sarcasm anymore because too often it's reality.



Not sarcasm, unfortunately. They have some sort of sex-ed class that states this.



You know why Baptists don't have sex standing up?

They're afraid someone would see them and think they were dancing.





I understand that oral sex is a sin there, too. Funny, considering his initials.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Conan71 on March 16, 2008, 09:46:19 AM
quote:
Originally posted by mr.jaynes

quote:
Originally posted by Conan71

Not much different than ORU requiring all employees to be non-tobacco users.

Being a private school, there's a whole lot of things they can include and exclude which a public school cannot.

If Cascia or BK wanted to limit employment strictly to Augustinian or Jesuit priests it's well within their rights.



With that in mind, a Jesuit education is a quality education indeed.



As is an Augustinian one. [;)]

Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: mr.jaynes on March 16, 2008, 10:19:23 AM
quote:
Originally posted by Conan71

quote:
Originally posted by mr.jaynes

quote:
Originally posted by Conan71

Not much different than ORU requiring all employees to be non-tobacco users.

Being a private school, there's a whole lot of things they can include and exclude which a public school cannot.

If Cascia or BK wanted to limit employment strictly to Augustinian or Jesuit priests it's well within their rights.



With that in mind, a Jesuit education is a quality education indeed.



As is an Augustinian one. [;)]



As is Augustinian, yes. Both Jesuits and Augustinians are renowned for a commitment to education, exemplified by very capable and learned teachers. Although Catholic schools have a religious component to them, it's my observation that it merely complements the quality of instruction, not undermines it.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: mspivey on March 17, 2008, 05:13:37 PM
Just to play devil's advocate, so to speak, I think it is a reasonable policy. While I'm not particularly religious, they are. They want the kids educated from a Victory Christian point of view. Why would they hire someone who doesn't believe the same way they do? Wouldn't make sense.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Conan71 on March 17, 2008, 09:06:04 PM
quote:
Originally posted by mspivey

Just to play devil's advocate, so to speak, I think it is a reasonable policy. While I'm not particularly religious, they are. They want the kids educated from a Victory Christian point of view. Why would they hire someone who doesn't believe the same way they do? Wouldn't make sense.



Exactly.  Why would or should they be required to hire, say the husband or wife from the athiest couple who sued the town of Hardesty, Oklahoma for discrimination.

Allow those who are willing to pay for and want their kids to have a sheltered Christian education to have it.  

Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: cannon_fodder on March 18, 2008, 08:19:50 AM
Oooh, ooooh... Jesuit educated here!
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: jamesrage on March 19, 2008, 04:27:26 PM
quote:
Originally posted by HoneySuckle

I called Victory Christian school today to ask about subbing there since I am a sub at Union High School.  Figured a nice, Christian or private type environment might be less problematic than the public school.

Only reason I picked this one is because I'm not too far from there, and also Holland Hall has their subs all in place.

Shocker, at least to me is that I was told you HAD to be a member of Victory Christian Church!

Is that legal?  Isn't that discrimination of some type?  Catholic schools hire non-Catholics, and so does Metro Christian (going to sub for them).





I would think that a private entity would be allowed to hire who ever they want.
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Daniel Wright on March 27, 2008, 06:49:08 PM
It is quite common,Children's many homes run by the Church of Christ require employees to be baptized members of the church in good standing.  
Also look at the ad's for the Indian Casinos around Oklahoma.  They all state Indian preference employer.  
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Hawkins on April 03, 2008, 11:17:55 AM
I have a friend who has been down on her luck and has been through numerous job ads and temp agency positions over the past few months.

On several occasions, she has been illegally told that she must be a Christian to get hired. A 2nd hand clothing store which I will not name most recently told her she had to be a regular churchgoer.

A dating service agency went one step further and told her that homosexuality was an abomination during her interview! (She has gay friends, and left that interview pretty ticked off).

Personal views, and highly illegal hiring practices, but unfortunately its kinda how it is here in this bible town.

Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: USRufnex on April 03, 2008, 01:10:27 PM
quote:
Originally posted by HoneySuckle

Quote
No.  A friend called about 3 hours later enquiring about employment as a counsellor and was told the same.  She then asked if this rule applied only to teachers, part-time workers and counsellors, and was told that it applied to ALL employees working at the school.

And no.  I would never dream of joining their church.



I spent a semester at that school but it was over 20 years ago.  

They always took pride in having "spirit-filled" teachers.

I don't think you'd be comfortable teaching there if you wouldn't be comfortable going to church at Victory.

I remember a textbook they were using for a medieval/renaissance history class I took my junior year.  It was from either Liberty Univ or Bob Jones Univ (not sure which) and had a prologue about the evils of "secular humanism."

Then the book went into great detail about the evils of the catholic church's history... and  the superiority of the "northern" renaissance (Martin Luther) over the Italian Renaissance (icky-secular humanism and nekkid statues)... Of course, this was all taught "in a spirit of LOVE!" ... [;)]
Title: Can a private school do this?
Post by: Conan71 on April 03, 2008, 01:16:33 PM
quote:
Originally posted by USRufnex

quote:
Originally posted by HoneySuckle

Quote
No.  A friend called about 3 hours later enquiring about employment as a counsellor and was told the same.  She then asked if this rule applied only to teachers, part-time workers and counsellors, and was told that it applied to ALL employees working at the school.

And no.  I would never dream of joining their church.



I spent a semester at that school but it was over 20 years ago.  

They always took pride in having "spirit-filled" teachers.

I don't think you'd be comfortable teaching there if you wouldn't be comfortable going to church at Victory.

I remember a textbook they were using for a medieval/renaissance history class I took my junior year.  It was from either Liberty Univ or Bob Jones Univ (not sure which) and had a prologue about the evils of "secular humanism."

Then the book went into great detail about the evils of the catholic church's history... and  the superiority of the "northern" renaissance (Martin Luther) over the Italian Renaissance (icky-secular humanism and nekkid statues)... Of course, this was all taught "in a spirit of LOVE!" ... [;)]




I learned far more about other world religions than I did Catholocism at Cascia Hall.  I took a survey of world religions class my Sr. year.  Fantastic class.